THE REFERENCE ROOM

Bottle Comparison

Compare the specifications recorded in Whiskey Scene’s bottle reviews. Compare two bottles free, or up to four with Scene membership and above.

Select bottles 2 of 2 selected

Choose up to 2 bottles. These are the specifications recorded in each Whiskey Scene review; a batch or later release may differ.

2 of 2 selected. Clear comparison

  • Old Fitzgerald 19 Year Remove
  • Really Old St. Nick 16 yr Remove

Onyx Amber 10yr Bourbon

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Origin Dragon's Milk

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Penelope Creme Brulee Bourbon

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Really Old St. Nick (10 yr)

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Really Old St. Nick 16 yr

Already selected

River Roots Port (BRS)

Remove a bottle to choose another.

River Roots Ruby Lotus

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Sagamore Rye DO

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Still Austin Distiller's Reserve

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Still Austin The Musician Bourbon

Remove a bottle to choose another.

The Balvenie

Remove a bottle to choose another.

The Senator 6 Yr Rye

Remove a bottle to choose another.

Reviewed specifications

Producer

Old Fitzgerald 19 Year
HH (Heaven Hill)
Really Old St. Nick 16 yr
Preservation Distillery

Proof

Old Fitzgerald 19 Year
100 proof
Really Old St. Nick 16 yr
255 proof

Style / Selection

Old Fitzgerald 19 Year
A favorite
Really Old St. Nick 16 yr
Purple bottle · A favorite

Price Recorded

Old Fitzgerald 19 Year
$15
Really Old St. Nick 16 yr
$799

Bottle / Maturation

Old Fitzgerald 19 Year
Bottle: 750 decanter bottle
Matured in: CNO — 17 yrs
Finished in: No finish
Really Old St. Nick 16 yr
Bottle: 750
Matured in: NCO

Whiskey Scene Verdict

Old Fitzgerald 19 Year
3.92 / 4 — Review
Really Old St. Nick 16 yr
3.99 / 4 — Buy

Review prices are individual observations, not MSRP or comparable pricing history. Follow each bottle title to its source review.

WS

Pour Notes

♦

A note from us with bottle picks, tasting ideas, new stories, and collector-minded observations.

Newsletter Signup

No noise. Just what matters.

Build Your Palate

Explore tasting notes, flavor cues, and simple ways to approach a pour with more confidence.

Contribute to Whiskey Scene

Whiskey Scene welcomes contributors and creative collaborators with a point of view on whiskey, cocktails, cigars, collecting, and modern drinking culture.

Partner with Whiskey Scene

Tasteful placement opportunities for brands, makers, and aligned partners looking to connect with a whiskey audience interested in both the past and future of the industry.

Customize consent preference

This website uses cookies

We use cookies to personalize content, provide social media features, and analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our analytics partners. You can change your preferences at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy.